Numerical issues in design of passive micro-mixers and its performance analysis using CFD

M. Amritkar¹ , A. Patil² , S. Barve³ , S. Gosavi⁴

Section:Research Paper, Product Type: Isroset-Journal
Vol.7 , Issue.1 , pp.10-17, Feb-2019

CrossRef-DOI:   https://doi.org/10.26438/ijsrpas/v7i1.1017

Online published on Feb 28, 2019

Copyright © M. Amritkar, A. Patil, S. Barve, S. Gosavi . This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
 

View this paper at   Google Scholar | DPI Digital Library

XML View     PDF Download

How to Cite this Paper

584 Views    255 Downloads    73 Downloads

Abstract :
Advection dominant fluid flows and transport processes in microfluidic mixing devices pose noteworthy challenges in design related simulations as regards numerical errors. In the present work, an unsteady flow model with decay constant was utilized for testing passive micro-mixer simulations for numerical error. The simulations were performed using OpenFOAM (Open-source Field Operation And Manipulation), a finite volume based open source software. Three types of hydrodynamic boundary conditions representing surface engineered device walls (hydro-active patches) were investigated as design test cases. Our study focuses upon simulated effect of these conditions on concentration profiles from the point of view of numerical error. We show that the model can be analytically treated in part to establish a particular feature in the simulated concentration profiles is a numerical artefact. Further, it is shown that this error is rectified either by changing the method of solving discretized equation or by coarsening the mesh. This process is also sensitive to the type of hydrodynamic boundary conditions imposed. A generalized grid convergence test we carried out attests to the reliability of these micro-fluidics simulation results, despite the fact that they display numerical artefacts. The paper addresses this anomaly to a strong interplay between difference equation solving methods, mesh parameters and boundary conditions in the partial differential equation (PDE) model for micro-flows in passive micro-mixers. Our investigation thus suggests that grid independence tests, instead of being based only upon cell variables and mesh parameters, should also be informed by PDE boundary conditions and difference equation solving methods.

Key-Words / Index Term :
Micro-fluidics , micro-mixer, PDE, CFD, OpenFOAM

References :
[1] E.A Mansur, M. Ye, Y. Wang, Y.C. Chin,”A state-of- the- art review of mixing in microfluidic mixers”, Journal of Chem. Eng., vol. 16, pp. 503–516, 2008
[2] N.T Nguyen, W. Zhingang,”Micromixers-A review”,Journal of Micromech. Microeng, vol.15, pp. R1–R16, 2005
[3] L.Capretto, W. Cheng, M.Hill, X. Zhang,”Micromixing within microfluidic devices”, Journal of Curr. Chem.,vol. 304, pp. 27–68, 2011
[4] V.Kumar, M. Paraschivoiu, K.D.P. Nigam,”Single-phase fluid flow and mixing in microchannels”, Chem. Eng. Sci.,vol. 66, pp. 1329–1373, 2011
[5] G.Cai, L. Xue, H. Zhang, J. Lin,”A review on micromixers”, Micromachines, vol. 8, pp. 274, 2017
[6] V.Hessel, H. Löwe, ,F. Schönfeld,”Micromixers—A review on passive and active mixing principles”, Chem. Eng. Sci. vol. 60, pp. 2479–2501, 2005
[7] L.Wang, D. Liu, X. Wang, X. Han,”Mixing enhancement of novel passive microfluidic mixers with cylindrical grooves”, Chem. Eng. Sci.,vol. 81, pp. 157–163, 2012
[8] A. Alam, A. Afzal, K.Y. Kim, ”Mixing performance of a planar micromixer with circular obstructions in a curved microchannel”,Chem. Eng. Res. Des. ,vol. 92, pp.423– 434 ,2014
[9] E. Demirel, M. Aral,”Unified analysis of multi-chamber contact tanks and mixing efficiency evaluation based on vorticity field”, Part II: Transport analysis. Water, vol. 8, pp. 537, 2016
[10] V.Y.Rudyak, A.V Minakov, A.A Gavrilov, A. Dekterev,”Modeling of flows in micromixers”, Journal of Thermophys. Aeromech. vol. 17, pp. 565–576, 2010
[11] M. Sandra, Strampraad, J.F.Marc, R.Wilfred, Hagen, and Simon de Vries,”Microsecond time- scale kinetics of transient biochemical reactions”,PLOS ONE 12(10): 0185888,2 017
[12] S.Sebastian, J. Hollmann, B. Schenkel, T.Röder, “Application-Oriented Analysis of Mixing Performance in Microreactors,”Organic Process Research and Development, Vol.16, pp. 1513−1522, 2012
[13] G. Hu, Dan-Di Li,” Multiscale phenomena in microfluidics and nanofluidics”, Chemical Engineering Science ,vol. 62, pp. 3443-3454,2007
[14] R. Kieffer, C. Charcosset, F.,Puel, D.Mangin, ”Numerical simulation of mass transfer in a liquid-liquid membrane contactor for laminar flow conditions”, Journal of Computers and Chemical Engineering, Vol.32, pp. 1325-1333, 2008
[15] R.C.Kolfschoten, J.W.Swarts, A.E.M. Janssen, R.M. Boom, ”Guidelines for optimal design of co-flow enzyme microreactors”,The Chemical Engineering Journal, vol. 172 pp. 1072-1077, 2011
[16] M.N.Kashid, F.latte, D.W. Agar, S. Turek, ”Computational modeling of slug flow in a capillary microreactor”, Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics. Vol. 203,pp. 487-497, 2007
[17] M.N.Kashid, D.W. Agar, S.Turek, ”CFD modelling of mass transfer with and without Chemical reaction in the liquid-liquid slug flow microreactor”, Chemical Engineering Science. vol.62,pp. 5102-5109, 2007
[18] A. Schuster, K. Sefiane, J. Ponton, ”Multiphase mass Transport in mini/micro-channels microreactor”,Chemical Engineering. Research and Design, Vol.86, pp. 527-534, 2008
[19] M.P.C.Marques, P. Fernandes, J.M.S. Cabral, P. Znidarsic-Plazl, I. Plazl,”On the feasibility of in situ steroid biotransformation and product recovery in microchannels”, Chemical Engineering Journal, vol.160, pp. 708-714, 2010
[20] T.Armaghani, A. Kasaeipoor, M, Izadi, I. Pop,” MHD natural convection and entropy analysis of a nanofluid inside T shaped baffled enclosure”, International Journal of numerical methods for heat and fluid flow,vol. 28, pp. 2916-2941, 2018
[21] S.R.Idelsohn, E. Oñate, ”Finite volumes and finite elements: Two ‘good friends”,International Journal of Numerical Methods in Engineering.Vol.37,pp.3323–3341,1994
[22] S.V.Patankar,“Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow”, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation: New York, Y, USA, 1980
[23] F.J.Christopher,“The issue of numerical uncertainty”, Applied Mathematical Modelling, vol. 26, pp.237–248, 2002
[24] M.B.Okuducu , M.M. Aral,“Performance Analysis and Numerical Evaluation of Mixing in 3-D T-Shape PassiveMicromixers”, micromachines, vol. 9 pp.210, 2018
[25] L.Minye, ”Computational study of convective–diffusive mixing in a microchannel mixer”,Chemical Engineering Science, vol. 66, pp. 2211–2223, 2011
[26] S.K.Godunov, V.S. Ryaben’kii,”Spectral stability criteria for boundary-value problems for non- self- adjoint difference equations”, Russian Mathematical Surveys ,vol. 18, pp. 1–12,1963
[27] L. Capretto, W.Cheng, M. Hill, X. Zhang ”Micro mixing within micro-fluidic devices”, Top Curr Chem , Springer–Verlag,vol. 304, pp.27-68, 2011
[28] J.Franjo, “Error analysis in finite volume CFD“, Ph.d Thesis, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Imperial College London, 2004
[29] A.Hay, M. Vissoneau,”CFD uncertainty analysis for turbulent flows using error equation method”, Workshop on CFD Uncertainty Analysis, At Lisbon, Portugal, 2004
[30] Z. Duan, P. Liang, “Numerical simulation of pressure drop for three dimensional rectangular microchannels”, Engineering computations, vol.35, pp. 2234-2254, doi:10.1108/EC-07-2017-0275,2018
[31] L.O.William , M.D.Sharon , M.B. Rutherford, V.D.Kathleen,F.A. Keneth, ”Error and Uncertainty in modeling and simulation “, Reliability Engineering and system safety, vol .75, pp. 333- 357, 2002
[32] P.J.Roache,“Fundamentals of computational fluid dynamics”, Hermosa publishers, ISBN-13: 978- 0913478097, 1995
[33] I. Celik, U. Ghia, P. Roache, C. Freitas,”Procedure of Estimation and Reporting of Uncertainty Due to Discretization in CFD Applications”, Journal of Fluids Engineering, ASME, vol. 130,10.1115/1.2960953, 2008
[34] F. Jamshidi, H. Heimel, M. Hasert, X. Cai, O. Deutschmann, H. Marschall,”On suitability of phase field and algebraic volume of fluid OpenFOAM solvers for gas liquid microfluidic applications”,vol.236, pp.72-85, 2019
[35 ] S. Idelsohn, N. Nigro, M. Gimenze, R. Rossi, M. Marti,”A fast and accurate method to solve the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations”, Engineering computations, vol. 30, pp. 197-222, 2012
[36] C. White, M.K. Borg, T.J. Scanlon, S.M. Longshaw, B. John , D.R. Emerson, J.M. Reese,“dsmcFoam+: An OpenFOAM based direct simulation Monte Carlo solver”, Journal of Computer Physics Communications, vol.224, pp.22-43,2018
[37] S. Sivakumar, E. Manikandan , “Novel synthesis of Optical Photoluminescence Properties and Supercapacitor application on Zn2+ doping sn1-xZnxo2 nanoparticles” International journal of Scientific Research in Physics and Applied Sciences, vol 6, pp.01-13, 2018
[38] J. K. Tavares, A. de Souza, J. de Oliveira, P.Wagner, Selene M.A, G. de Souza, “Modeling of the
controlled release of betacarotene into anhydrous ethanol from microcapsules”, pp.25-35, 2016
[39] L.Yutong, K. Pekkan, S. Jones, A.Yoganathan, “The Effects of Different Mesh Generation Methods on Computational Fluid Dynamics Analysis and Power Loss in assessment in Total Cavopulmonary Connection”, Journal of biomechanical Engineering, vol. 126, pp.594-603, 2004